Debunking the 25% Myth

My dad called yesterday, asking, “Wind turbines do run for more than 25% of the time, don’t they?”. Seems he read an opinion piece in his favourite fair ‘n’ balanced rag (The Telegraph) that said that wind turbines only run 25% of the time.

I see this factoid popping up more and more from the anti-wind crowd. It’s a particularly difficult one to refute in the press, as by the time you’ve tried to explain the difference between capacity factor and operation time, you’ve lost them. Or gone over your allotted time/word count, at least.

I’ve got a year’s production data from WindShare/Toronto Hydro‘s turbine in front of me. It’s on a marginal site, one that probably wouldn’t be developed by a commercial entity. So, does it run for more than 25% of the time?

Yes; the turbine is generating 63% of the time. I’ve defined generating as providing a net export of power to the grid. Our turbine’s a bit more cranky than most, and I have a suspicion that our metering system is dropping some production, but even so, 63% is way more than the claimed 25%. So it gives me great pleasure to say:

MYTH: Wind turbines only run for 25% of the time.
BUSTED! Wind turbines run at the very least 60% of the time, usually more.

(I can’t guarantee that Country Guardian won’t quote me out of context. I could make a cheap shot about not blaming them for their paymasters in the nuclear industry requiring value for money, but I won’t …)

3 thoughts on “Debunking the 25% Myth”

  1. I think I can relate. As a writer, I might spend time “working” and if I’m lucky I “generate” ideas 25% of the time… heck, if it were 60% I’d probably be certifiably insane.

  2. I’m not stretching the truth in the slightest, Brendan. The original article implied that wind turbines were only turning 25% of the time. They run for a heckuva lot more than that, and I make no apologies for my original remarks.

    It’s too easy to get hung up on rated power. F’rinstance, would you consider a car to be useful if it ran at 25% of its capacity factor? I think you’d be amazed if it could. 25% capacity factor for a car would be running it flat out for six hours a day, every day — something that few car owners do.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *